Baruch (1-0) led from start to finish and opened the second half with an 18-2 run to build a comfortable 45-21 lead.
They held Arcadia (0-1) to 23-percent shooting (16-69) and one three-pointer in 24 attempts.
Cheick Fadika, a member of last year's CUNYAC All-Rookie Team, scored 18 points, 13 rebounds, three block shots, and two steals.
Robi Davidson scored 14 points on four-of-seven shooting from three-point range, while Division I Binghamton University transfer Louis Karis added nine points.
Baruch will face the winner of the New Jersey City University and City Tech match up being played later this evening.